Episode notes · Sponsored episode

How to Prove Value to Your Customer Before the Renewal

By Bayron Toruño, with Steven Lewandowski · 18 November 2026

In short

  • Usage, tickets and health scores show activity, not value. Customers renew for the result they bought you for.
  • Get the business case from sales at handover and keep it alive as a short value plan the customer can see.
  • Ask what your customer needs to prove, to whom, and by when. That gives you a shared target.

The renewal is three weeks away. You open your deck and it's all there: logins, tickets closed, a green health score. And still you have a feeling the customer is going to ask one question you can't answer. What did we actually get for this?

I talked about this with Steven Lewandowski. Steven led customer success at Signavio, HubSpot and SAP, and he co-founded addressable value, a company that helps software companies show the value of their product. (Quick note: addressable value is also the sponsor of this episode.)

We started with AI. A July 2026 BCG survey of 152 CEOs found that nearly 9 in 10 see cost or revenue benefits from AI in some areas, but only 14% have clearly defined the P&L impact for all their AI initiatives. I expected Steven to be surprised. He wasn't. For him, it's the same value problem customer success has always had, just with a new label.

Here's what I took from the conversation, as steps you can use with your own accounts.

1. Stop counting activity and calling it value

Steven has worked with a lot of CS platforms over the years, and he sees the same pattern. Customer success was meant to be proactive and about outcomes. In practice, many teams ended up measuring tickets, adoption and a health score.

"Health score count, right? Which is not value, right? This is all activity internal metrics they're measuring."

He told a story from an event in Dublin. In a room of two or three hundred CS leaders, someone asked how many thought their health score was predictive. Maybe three hands went up.

What to do: look at your next QBR deck. For every slide, ask: is this activity, or is this a result the customer cares about? If it's all activity, Steven's advice is simple. Don't walk in with only those numbers. If the right people are in the room, they won't be interested.

2. Keep the business case alive after the deal

In bigger deals, sales often builds a business case with the customer: what they'll get, with numbers, usually in a spreadsheet and a slide deck. Then the deal is signed and, as Steven put it, the business case disappears. It's not even part of most good handovers.

So a year later the renewal comes, and the CSM has no idea what was promised. Steven described what happens next:

"Let's give them some numbers to make them see that we're actively working with them and prove to them that it's valuable, which is not the same thing as proving a business case."

What to do:

  • At handover, ask sales for the business case, not just the stakeholder list. What outcome did the customer buy?
  • Turn it into a short value plan: the goal, who owns it on the customer's side, and the number you agreed on.
  • Keep updating it. Show the customer the progress regularly, not only before the renewal.

If you inherit an account with no business case, Steven suggests going back to the customer and asking about it directly. You talked to our sales team a year ago about specific outcomes. Who needs to prove that internally? How can we help?

3. Ask what your customer needs to prove, to whom, and by when

Steven said something that stuck with me. The best vendors ask their customers questions. What do you need to achieve? Who's involved? By when? Who cares about the result?

When a customer can tell you "I need to increase upsell revenue by 17% by December", you finally have something to work with. Steven called this shared accountability: you're a partner helping them reach a target, not a vendor reporting usage.

What to do: pick one account this week and write down three things. What does your sponsor have to prove to their management in the next year? Who do they report it to? When? If you can't answer, that's your next customer conversation.

4. Start small, and tie time saved to a goal

This one is from the buyer side, but it works for any tool your customer buys, including yours. Steven gave an example. An AI assistant saves you 30 minutes a day. Where does that time go? More deals? Better customer calls? Or coffee? If nobody decides, it never shows up in the results.

His advice for buyers: don't roll a tool out to everyone and then try to measure "success" across hundreds of different activities. Start with one use case in a controlled setting, decide the outcome you want, and measure that. In the quick-fire round, his answer to what buyers should never do was short: not have a use case identified.

What to do: when your customer says your product "saves time", ask what they want to do with that time. Fewer escalations? Shorter deal cycles? More output? That's the number to track together.

5. Own what you send, even if AI made it

AI can take the busy work off a CSM's plate, and Steven is all for that. But he has been in too many presentations where people clearly saw the slides for the first time while presenting them.

"In the end it's your job and whatever you show, whatever you say, whatever you prepare, whatever you send out, carries your name."

What to do: use AI to prepare the QBR, then read every slide before the meeting. If a number is there, know where it came from.

6. When a customer may not renew, ask questions

I asked Steven what not to do when a customer doesn't see the value and probably won't renew. His answer: not ask questions. Nobody in B2B enjoys replacing a platform, so if they leave, there's a real reason. Maybe you missed signals, or you never knew what they wanted to achieve. Go into that call to understand what went wrong, not to defend your numbers.

Steven also told me that at addressable value, a customer with no metrics to measure their outcomes already counts as a churn risk. That's a good test for your own book of business.

Your next step

Take your next renewal. Before you build the deck, write one sentence: "This customer bought us to achieve ___, and here is how far they got." If you can't fill in the blank, start there.

The full conversation goes further, including why nobody believes ROI calculators anymore and why Steven thinks some companies turned customer success into rebranded support. Have a look at the full episode:

Steven, thank you for keeping it so practical. 🙌